Your how-to: Establishing benchmarks for mental health initiative success

Category
Leadership and Governance
Sub-category
Performance Measurement and Reporting
Level
Maturity Matrix Level 2

Establishing benchmarks for mental health initiative success refers to the concept of establishing benchmarks or standards against which the success of mental health initiatives in your workplace can be measured. This involves identifying key indicators of mental health well-being, setting clear and realistic goals around these, and tracking progress towards them over time. 

These benchmarks will likely include both quantitative measures, such as reductions in absenteeism and staff turnover rates, and qualitative aspects, such as improved morale and happiness among employees. 

It should be noted that different businesses will have different benchmarks based on their specific needs, industry, organisational culture and resources. Therefore, it's crucial to personalise these benchmarks to your own context. As per the Australian WHS Act 2011, employers also have a legal duty to ensure the psychological health and safety of their workers, making the establishment of such benchmarks beneficial legally too.

Step by step instructions

Step 1

Understand the Importance of Mental Health Benchmarks: Educate yourself on the significance of mental health initiatives in the workplace and the benefits having clear, measurable outcomes can bring for both employee wellbeing and overall business success.

Step 3

Conduct a Mental Health Audit: Survey all workers to gain an in-depth understanding of the current mental health landscape within your organisation. This could involve anonymous surveys, one-to-one interviews or focus groups.

Step 5

Develop a Mental Health Action Plan: Create a comprehensive plan, outlining initiatives your business will employ to meet the established benchmarks. This could include workplace wellbeing programs, counselling services or mental health first aid training for staff.

Step 7

Monitor Progress and Regularly Review Benchmarks: Establish a system for tracking your progress towards these benchmarks. Be prepared to revise your benchmarks and action plan as necessary - these should be flexible and adaptable to changing circumstances or unexpected difficulties. Make sure to review your benchmarks at least annually.

Step 2

Identify Key Indicators: Think about what mental health wellness looks like for your business. This might include lower rates of absenteeism, fewer incidents of workplace conflict or high levels of employee satisfaction. Remember that these indicators should be specific to your organisation's needs and culture.

Step 4

Set Clear, Realistic Goals: Based on your identified indicators and audit data, set achievable targets. These could range from reducing sick days due to mental ill-health by 10% within a year to ensuring 80% of staff rate their mental wellbeing as good or above in an annual survey.

Step 6

Communicate Your Benchmarks and Plan: Ensure all stakeholders, particularly staff, are aware of your mental health benchmarks and how you plan to achieve them. Communication should be ongoing, ensuring everyone is aligned with your goals and progress.

Step 8

Recognise Success and Foster a Positive Mental Health Culture: When benchmarks are met, make sure to recognise this. Celebrating successes can help foster a positive mental health culture and encourage ongoing commitment to the initiatives.

Use this template to implement

To ensure you can execute seamlessly, download the implementation template.

Pitfalls to avoid

Neglecting Legal Obligations
Lack of Expert Consultation

Mental health is a complex issue that requires informed attention. Without seeking advice from mental health professionals, businesses risk implementing initiatives that may cause more harm than good. You need to base your strategies on evidence, clinical guidelines and best practices from professionals in the field to guarantee effectiveness and safety.

Overlooking Ongoing Measurement and Evaluation

The launching of your initiative is just the start; failing to measure and evaluate the effectiveness of your scheme over time could mean you miss crucial signs that your strategy needs tweaking. Regular appraisals are the best ways to identify areas of improvement for the initiative and gauge its impact on your employees' wellbeing.

Inadequate Employee Consultation and Engagement

To be successful, a mental health initiative must be relevant and accessible to all workers. Failure to consult with employees about what they need from such a scheme might result in low engagement and lacklustre results. These initiatives should not be top-down decisions; instead, involve your team from the planning stages to ensure you are addressing their needs effectively.

Setting Unrealistic Benchmarks

While it's crucial to have ambitious goals, setting unrealistic benchmarks for your mental health initiative may set your team up for failure. Unrealistic expectations can lead to feelings of inadequacy and increased pressure, potentially exacerbating the mental health issues you're aiming to address. Ensure against this by setting achievable, measurable and relevant benchmarks.

Insufficient Training and Education

Without proper training, managers and team leaders might not be equipped to support their team members effectively. You must ensure all staff, particularly those in leadership roles, understand the nature of mental health and are equipped with the skills to handle mental health-related situations appropriately.